Harris County eviction outcomes vary by judge, and landlords get to choose, Kinder Institute report finds

0
New research from Rice University's Kinder Institute found that eviction rulings in Harris County can vary widely depending on which judge hears the case, and landlords get to make that choice.
New research from Rice University's Kinder Institute found that eviction rulings in Harris County can vary widely depending on which judge hears the case, and landlords get to make that choice.

HARRIS COUNTY, Texas (KTRK) — New research from Rice University’s Kinder Institute found that eviction rulings in Harris County can vary widely depending on which judge hears the case, and landlords get to make that choice.

The Kinder Institute looked at more than 320,000 eviction cases filed in the county from 2019 to 2024.

Justice of the Peace precincts have two courts, each led by an elected judge. Researchers found that while those judges serve the same precinct, their eviction rulings can look very different.

“We did find that within each precinct, across those two judges, you could have very different rates of judgments in favor of the landlords or the tenants or dismissals,” Steve Sherman, a Kinder Institute researcher, said.

In some cases, researchers found the gap between judgments favoring landlords was more than 12 percentage points.

“The property owner, the property manager who files the eviction suit, gets to choose which of those two judges in the precinct the case goes to,” Sherman said.

Researchers said they could not pinpoint exactly why those differences exist, but said it raises questions about fairness in a system where landlords can choose their judge and tenants cannot.

“Even within precincts, we can find very large differences in the number of eviction cases that go to each of the two judges,” Sherman said.

But once a tenant loses, the fight may not be over.

Sherman said they also found that appealing an eviction case might actually benefit the tenant more.

“Appeals generally do work out for the tenant,” Sherman said. “They do have a higher rate of final judgments in their favor.”

Researchers recommended changes like randomly assigning cases between the two judges in each precinct.

This story comes from our news partner ABC13 Houston.